REVIEW: Peter Gabriel brings big thoughts to Chase Center

Peter Gabriel

Peter Gabriel performs at Chase Center in San Francisco on Oct. 11, 2023. Steve Carlson/STAFF.

SAN FRANCISCO — Peter Gabriel brought a multimedia extravaganza to Chase Center Wednesday night, delivering not just a feast for the eyes and ears, but lots of big ideas to mull over during the marathon, three-hour concert.

The show began with Gabriel onstage alone, dressed in black and talking about time.



“Time is the big boss, but there is one way to wiggle out of those claws: imagination,” Gabriel told the audience as he acted with an illuminated microphone, a meteorite hitting earth billions of years ago, bringing the basic ingredients for life.

Peter Gabriel

Peter Gabriel performs at Chase Center in San Francisco on Oct. 11, 2023.

He then introduced his longtime collaborator and bass legend, Tony Levin, who’s played with everyone from Paul Simon to King Crimson. Together they played delicate and heartfelt ballad “Washing of the Water,” from Gabriel’s 1992 album, Us. The rest of the band, dressed in black, appeared on stage and together they sat in a semi-circle as if arrayed around a campfire. The band then performed another song from Up, “Playing For Time,” which grew from sedate mandolin and stings into a raucous, foot-stomping groove.

Despite a deep back catalog, fully half of the concert—which was divided over two sets with a short intermission—was comprised of songs from Gabriel’s forthcoming album, i/o, due out later this year. The enthusiastic crowd seemed to know many of these songs already, as Gabriel began releasing a single from the album every full moon starting on Jan. 6.



The band retreated from the campfire-like gathering at the center of the stage to form a more traditional backline. Before playing “Panopticom,” Gabriel explained that he had grown up on a dairy farm where the initials AI stood for “artificial insemination.”

Peter Gabriel

Peter Gabriel performs at Chase Center in San Francisco on Oct. 11, 2023.

“Now the whole human race is receiving AI,” Gabriel said.

Other songs from i/o included “Four Kinds of Horses,” with its graceful horn melodies, the lush orchestration of “Playing For Time,” the earthy groove of “This is Home,” and “Court,” which Gabriel said was “a song about justice.”

The crowd remained seated for most of the concert, but several hits coaxed attendees out of their chairs for some lively dancing. Gabriel asked them to sing along on “Digging in the Dirt.” The iconic MTV hits from the ’80s, “Big Time” and Sledgehammer,” the latter of which concluded closed the first set, drew huge cheers.



The visual component was supplied by a set of screens behind the band that displayed artwork created specially in collaboration with Gabriel. During “Road to Joy,” images of rotating middle fingers created by Chinese artist and human rights crusader Ai Wei Wei spun on the screen. Animated and psychedelic paramecium swam on the screens at one point, and elegant oil paintings provided a less dynamic backdrop at another.

Peter Gabriel

Peter Gabriel performs at Chase Center in San Francisco on Oct. 11, 2023.

The backing band seemed to move effortlessly between the various musical dynamics. Ayanna Witter-Johnson provided incredible backing vocals on sentimental ballad “Don’t Give Up,” as well as a cello solo from a platform above and behind the stage during the second set. During “Sledgehammer,” Gabriel, guitarist David Rhodes and bassist Tony Levin, who’ve been collaborating for more than 40 years, went through a series of choreographed dance moves.

Peter Gabriel closed the second set with his debut single from 1977, “Solsbury Hill,” much to the crowd’s obvious delight. He thanked the audience, which then held up phone lights, lighting up Chase Center like digital fireflies.



Follow photographer Steve Carlson at Instagram.com/SteveCarlsonSF and Twitter.com/SteveCarlsonSF.

(4) Comments

  1. S28

    Where were the hits? The crowd was restless and the energy was amazing once a crowd favorite was played, we then took our seats while new material was played in anticipation of the next hit, to only take our seats again. Visuals were great, sound was very loud and encompassing, no complaints!

  2. Martin Estrada

    He did play a couple songs from UP, but Playing for time was not one of them. I like his new songs a lot, though it has taken some time for them to grow on me. This show enforced to me what they mean and just how exceptional they are. It was a treat to see him on this tour. The show was well attended, and the crowd was into it.

  3. John

    PG was one of the few artists I have left on my bucket list. So I popped for a great seat. I had high expectations. I get that Peter is in his 70s so him running all over the stage was unrealistic. But I didn’t expect the show would start with the band of 10 extremely talented artists seated for the first song or two. A very low energy start. After 20-30 minutes of new songs, where the audience remained seated, he broke out one of his hits. Everyone rose and the glow from cell phones shooting video took over. Then everyone sat stoic for the next song, which was off the new album. At least three of his “new” songs sounded like old songs by others. One by the Beatles, another that was so similar to the original that I found myself singing its lyrics. The assembled artists, all excellent, were twice the number needed to the point of muddying the core melody. The female singer was excellent and paired beautifully with Peter. Bottom line is Peter is the artist and gets to put on the show he wants to put on. But overall it was a low energy show with below expectation production. After a 20 year hiatus I had much higher expectations, especially given the seat cost of $250. Thanks but no thanks, Peter.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *