ALBUM REVIEW: John Mayer blends his various eras on ‘Sob Rock’

John Mayer Sob Rock, John Mayer, Sob Rock

Sob Rock is an ode to all the different eras of the sound of John Mayer. The album, his eighth, feels like a trip through the ages, with sounds reminiscent of both Room for Squares and even the oft-forgotten years of Paradise Valley.

Sob Rock
John Mayer
Columbia, July 16
6/10

One of Mayer’s goals on this 10-track offering was to venture deeper into the realm of pop music than he had in the past. But instead of heading straight into the belly of the beast, he takes measured steps with songs like “Last Train Home” and “New Light.” The former has a strong 1980s vibe from opening keyboards and guitar chords straightaway. He also enlists the help of Maren Morris, who sings backup to give it another layer of sheen without being an outright pop song.



“New Light” is a bit more upbeat and poppy and less rock guitar than Mayer typically employs, and a heavier backbeat. Since he doesn’t take the full leap, he creates a sound somewhere in the middle of pop and blues rock.

For those looking for Mayer’s deeply personal acoustic songwriting, there are songs here for you, too. “Shouldn’t Matter But It Does” is a slow-burning, heart-wrenching song about moving on from heartbreak, even after many years. The song reminisces on what the future might have been like, decisions he could have made differently and, ultimately, how, “it shouldn’t matter but it does.”

Another track where Mayer allows a glimpse into his soul is “Guess I Just Feel Like,” which sounds like an internal monologue set to a simple guitar tune. He sings about anxiety, disappointment and feeling lost; however, the song ends with a somewhat hopeful note and an extended electric guitar solo at the end. Lyrically, these songs could have from from2017’s Search For Everything. Sonically, they feel like a strong callback to 2012’s Born and Raised. It’s a blend that ends up working very nicely.



John Mayer is also no stranger to love ballads. Sob Rock is no different, as he includes a number of love songs to fuel the narrative that seems to be about time-traveling through his discography. The self-explanatory “All I Want Is To Be With You,” is sweet and slow Western composition. It’s not about grand gestures of romance or heartbreak.

“Til The Right One Comes,” is a love song in a sense, even if the subject here is someone he’s yet to meet. Mayer’s attention to detail with songwriting about love leads to a number of beautifully written, nuanced songs and has only gotten more complex as his career has developed.

A few songs here feel out of place in their experimental nature, in both sound and lyricism. “Why You No Love Me” could pass for a Jimmy Buffet cover with a lack of depth. “Wild Blue” had the potential to be better but was overdone with too many instrumental additions and vocal modulations.

Still, it’s good to hear from John Mayer again. It feels like this one was more about himself than the people who will listen to it. It’s sometimes too familiar, but occasionally, it’s transformative.

Follow writer Piper Westrom at Twitter.com/plwestrom.

(8) Comments

  1. raberjr

    6 out of 10? really? That's one way to get some responses. lol. I must applaud you for not just giving the album a 9 b/c it's JM. There are too many pedestrian albums and auto-tuned musicians getting way higher reviews than they deserve these days. But, i'm thinking John ain't one of those musicians. Admittedly, i've only heard 4 of the pre-released songs...those alone get the album 6 out of 10, though. to each his own....

  2. Brian

    I wonder why you only mention songs, that are currently shared or that we had a sneak-peaked on? There's nothing about Shot in the Dark and many more.

  3. BILL

    I don’t think people are excited about this album because Last Train Home did so poorly on the charts. For me, I don’t understand why he would try to recreate soft rock of the 80’s when he’s way more talented than this. The 80’s music was eclectic but he decided pick the genre that not memorable which will make SOB ROCK unmemorable. He no longer has the star power to convince us SOB ROCK is rock.

  4. Lulu

    Sorry folks, I really enjoyed this album! I'm listening to it as a stand-alone, being that I don't own any other JM albums to compare it to. It has warm melodic tones and soulful riffs that I could listen to over and over. Just appreciate it for what it is and don't try to compare it to anything else. Comparing albums is like comparing wines, it comes down to individual taste.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *