REVIEW: ATEEZ highlights the hip-hop in K-pop at Oakland tour opener

ATEEZ

ATEEZ performs at Oakland Arena in Oakland on Nov. 5, 2022. Steve Carlson/STAFF.

OAKLAND — On the heels of two arena shows in Seoul, South Korea, K-pop up-and-comers ATEEZ kicked off the North American portion of their second arena tour of 2022 at Oakland Arena on Saturday, giving Bay Area fans a glimpse of the octet’s hard-hitting sound.

Unlike recent K-pop acts who’ve played the venue, like Seventeen and Stray Kids, ATEEZ’s persona lay mostly in the rap realm. While most of the group had opportunities to show off their abilities, rapper Song Min-gi shined brightest with his heavy, gravel-edged baritone. Mingi, as he’s known to fans, had a rapping voice that might fit right in the horror-core genre. And when he was delivering his lines, people took notice.



The current trek, named The Fellowship: Break the Wall tour, will take the band through about 10 cities in the U.S. and Canada. Most of those markets, like Oakland, are new to the band—at least in terms of arenas. Prior to pandemic lockdowns, the largest rooms ATEEZ played in the U.S. were much smaller clubs. While the Oakland show wasn’t a sellout, thousands of fans still made a statement by arriving early and immediately crowded around the group’s stage and a catwalk to a large second stage in the middle of the arena floor.

ATEEZ

ATEEZ performs at Oakland Arena in Oakland on Nov. 5, 2022.

The mood of the show was a joyous one. The group—which includes singers and rappers Hongjoong, Seonghwa, Yunho, Yeosang, San, Wooyoung and Jongho—made no mention of South Korea’s Oct. 29 crowd surge tragedy, where 156 people died and more were injured. The group had donated 100 million won (about $71,000) to relief efforts, however.

The concert began with a surprise guest opener: trainee group KQ Fellaz 2 (think of them as a minor league team for ATEEZs management company, KQ Entertainment). This group of 10 members delivered a quick-hitting two-song set with emphatic choreography.  The first song, “Geek,” was rap-centric. The second song featured Southeast Asian and even Bollywood sounds, but was equally bass-heavy. If this was a rock concert, attendees would likely have shrugged off an unknown opening act. But the fans in the building went wild for KQ Fellaz 2.



Luckily, it wasn’t more than 10 minutes before the evening’s headliners took the stage. ATEEZ itself is a relatively new group, having debuted in 2018.

ATEEZ

ATEEZ performs at Oakland Arena in Oakland on Nov. 5, 2022.

Judging by this performance, the group is still figuring some things out about its music and performance. But it offered a stylistic buffet of the hard-hitting rap as well as EDM bangers and some songs that were influenced either by R&B, pop or even reggaeton.

A lot of the rap-led songs came early in the set as ATEEZ opened with the foreboding “New World” as well as bangers “Answer” and “Sector 1.” The music followed a suspenseful intro where about 10 of the group’s dancers entered wearing all black, their heads hooded and faces masked. The octet, also covered in black and hooded, appeared between them, raised on a lift. Everyone then made the walk to the stage in the middle of the floor and back to the main stage, where the ATEEZ members were raised on three platforms covered in LED screens.



It wasn’t all rapping. On “Answer,” the various vocalists mixed in power pop (which made this song stand out even more) and powerful balladry. By the third song, the black robes were off and the group was clad in black outfits with sparkly accents.

ATEEZ

ATEEZ performs at Oakland Arena in Oakland on Nov. 5, 2022.

Then came the introductions; the first of several breaks where the show stalled. ATEEZ gets bonus points for not relying on a translator until the end of the show, but the members often talked over one another, making the conversations harder to follow.

Other highlights included “HALA HALA,” with smooth vocals by Jongho and others. It ended with a dance breakdown and the group feigning exhaustion, collapsing to the stage floor, before a video intermission about finding hope in despair, relying on each other, reuniting after lockdowns and about the group’s individual life goals. If anything held the thematic center of the show together, it was this message about overcoming obstacles.



At this point, ATEEZ transitioned mostly to poppier, dance-oriented songs, such as “Dazzling Light,” with Seonghwa and Wooyoung ringing in the high notes. R&B ballad “Mist” also stood out among the harder-edged material with it’s lighter touches and modulated vocals. ATEEZ paired up motivational-sounding numbers “Sunrise” and “My Way,” as well as tropical sounding “Illusion” and “Wave.” Of the latter pair, the first featured some fun animated visuals of palm trees and volcanic mountains, and the second colorful rainbow lighting. Even the following “Win,” performed on a faux pirate ship, featured a samba-inflected melody, even if it was a banger.

The group saved some of its biggest party songs for the end with the likes of the hyperactive “Say My Name,” on which the octet demonstrated its best mix of singing, rapping and dancing at the same time; “ROCKY;” tempo-changing “Wonderland” and industrial-sounding “Cyberpunk,” which included vocals that followed a descending scale and a choreographed chair dance after which all eight members where glistening with sweat. By this point, several costume changes in, the group was dressed in black tactical gear. It got the loudest shrieks of the night.

Follow editor Roman Gokhman at Twitter.com/RomiTheWriter. Follow photographer Steve Carlson at Instagram.com/SteveCarlsonSF and Twitter.com/SteveCarlsonSF.

(16) Comments

  1. Jennifer Cserenyi

    Please do not EVER write about ATEEZ again. You should be ASHAMED! Calling this insulting, ignorant and xenophobic “article” journalism. Clearly you are as ignorant about ATEEZ and KPOP as your disgusting backhanded compliments and shade prove you are. Maybe stick to the sh*t you DO know, by the looks of it, sure as hell ain’t music.

  2. Michelle

    Okay, I have a question. As a co founder and co editor of a supposedly journalistic magazine or whatever this is cause let's face it, no one has heard of it. How is it that as the person who claims these big titles such as yourself doesn't know how to write a professional, streamlined and well put article with little to no facts nor research and still have the decency to publish an article about a group that has charted billboard numerous times and had embarked on TWO sold out world tours? The unprofessionalism and disrespectful terminology used in whatever piece of writing this is because it's not concise in any way, is absolutely abhorrent.

  3. Catherine Turley

    Bring on the crazy. I'm a die hard fan, but I'm also a normal person. Everybody doesn't have to love everything about ateez or any other kpop group. It's an honest review from one person's perspective. The only thing I disagree with is making a statement about 'figuring things out' and not elaborating. I think they know who they are but, as with several kpop groups, they venture into multiple genres as a rule. I believe that's actually part of their group concept.

  4. D

    I think this article had a few misses. ATEEZ's persona doesn't lie mostly in the rap realm, especially when compared to Stray Kids. SKZ's music is written by their rappers so it's much more rap-centric than ATEEZ'S which tries to highlight both their rappers and their incredible vocal line. Their youngest, Jongho, is one of the best male vocalists in Kpop's 4th gen and most of their music shows off his skills. Their prepandemic tour at small venues and this concert not being a sellout were mentioned, but the author overlooked the fact they had a sold-out world tour (which included the US) at large venues earlier this year. The fact they've been topping the charts worldwide including being one of the few Kpop groups to rank in Billboard 200's top three was also missing. I'm not sure why the Itaewon tragedy was brought up, but they did wear black armbands and have a moment of silence for the victims when they performed in Seoul. At the end of Hala Hala, the members didn't feign exhaustion, they feigned breaking their own necks as fitting the lyrics about a suicide squad. I suggest the author watch the MV to see what they missed. Finally, KQ Fellaz 2 are trainees that will soon debut. So, calling them rookies is more accurate than calling them minor league.

  5. Nhaila

    Hello, I am happy that Ateez is being discussed since I'm a fan. It's normal for the writer to not understand fully the composition of Kpop concerts in particular the talking portions. Obviously, these boys are not native EN speakers, but they try hard. I personally love hearing them speak throughout the concerts because it's a time we have to interact with them. These "ments" are primarily for fans, aka Atinys. The only thing I was hoping to see in the article that I did not was Johno and his amazing singing ability, which is out of this world. I feel that we as fans sometimes take that for granted. Thanks for at least showcasing this band to a local demographic.

  6. Dhad

    I read articles for information, which this contained. I think fans looking for one-sided praise were probably at the concert and not reading about it. This article gave a good overview of the concert and an idea of how this band is different from every other Kpop band. Meanwhile the comments shed a lot of light on its fan-base.

    1. Yvo

      He didn't give a good overview at all . Ateez isn't a rap based group, Stray Kids are. They also aren't figuring things out about their music and performance. They actually have a story line and even though they perform songs from different albums, they tie into the story line. If he'd done the slightest research, he'd see how easily they connect. It is also very common for kpop acts to do different genres. Ateez does the ones they like but also that have a purpose in their story line. In Hala Hala, they snap their own necks at the end, not pretend to be exhausted and Hala stands for Hearts Awakened Live Alive, the same message being delivered in songs like New World, Sunrise, My Way, Thanxx ,Guerrilla, Wonderland and more . A simple check would have shown that. He speaks as if Ateez is finding their way to perform in bigger venues when the fact is they sold out arenas Before the pandemic and hold the record as being the fastest act to sell a 100k+ seat tour in the shortest time from debut in Kpop History For a group from a small Korean label to out do big Korean label acts speaks to their talent and pull. That postponed sold out world tour was held earlier this year and this is their second arena tour this year so why is he clueless?

  7. Raptor

    I see some fans are only interested in hearing how great their band is. Reviews are always subjective, but there is nothing hateful here at all. Very professional and thoughtful review as far as I can see. I have no bias on the band either way, but after reading some of these comments I’m a little worried.

    1. yv

      How can you say it's thoughtful if you don't know anything about Ateez? It wasn't professional as he stated many things that aren't true. Before the pandemic, Ateez sold out a world arena tour that was postponed due to covid and that tour was held earlier this year. Simply google ? They aren't a rap based focus, Stray Kids are and the fact he said they are and You thinking it's a professional review shows how easily misinformation is believed. If he knew anything about kpop, he'd know it's common to do different genres. Ateez isn't "finding themselves". They have albums already done that tie into their story line and many songs from totally diff albums and genres were done at the same time. That's pre-planning which they did Even before their debut. Western artists don't have story lines. Even the songs are arranged differently. Kpop will be 4 minutes long as the standard and our western artists are generally 2.3 minutes. Hala Hala is Hearts Awakened Live Alive, is a 2019 release. New World is from the 2022 album and is telling people to open their eyes and their minds. Ateez Wave mv tells people to open their eyes. Say My Name tells people to focus on them and hear their message. My Way is in their debut and it even tells people to not be swayed from their dreams. Now all these different songs send the same message over and over. That's how detailed their story line is and that's 4 years now since their anniversary was 0ct 24th, 2018 yet this writer says Ateez is finding themselves. No, he simply didn't research in the slightest.

  8. am

    "ATEEZ gets bonus points for not relying on a translator until the end of the show," What a weird and unnecessary comment. Obviously english isn't their first language, but they do know it. They use a translator towards the end of the show when each member wants to give their thanks to ATINYs(their fans) for attending and supporting their endeavors especially after their pre-pandemic tour had to be rescheduled. Also bringing up the Itaewon tragedy was weird considering they did donate as stated in the article and if you did a quick Google search you would be aware of the fact that on their second tour date for SK a day after the tragedy they had a moment of silence for the victims before the show started and wore black ribbons for them as well.

  9. Lea

    I’ve been going to concerts for 30 years. I took my daughter to ateez in January and can honestly say that this is absolutely the best, most energetic, exciting concert I have ever been to. I want to go this time around probably more than my daughter does. And we just went to NCT. No comparison.

  10. Anonymous

    I am an atiny (an ateez fan), I went to this concert, it was awesome, and I find nothing offensive at all about this article. You people complaining about it are the problem, freaking out over nothing and giving kpop fans a bad reputation when we are already not taken seriously by many people (partly for good reason). Stop being so fucking defensive and aggressive. How is this article xenophobic? I thought it was pretty detailed and showed knowledge of different musical genres, and it doesn't say anything bad about ATEEZ. And it's a subjective review anyway.

  11. Clara

    Please do some research about Ateez before writting about them. The writter had no clue about the Ateez lore. He said himself that "judging by this performance, the group is still figuring out about their music and performane"... Ateez performances are totally based on their lore and that there's a storyline attached to it. They're not a simple band that goes in, sing and finish. You have to understand their lore and storyline! Basically, there's a parallell universe, where they live different lives, that's why their style varies from scene to scene...

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *