ALBUM REVIEW: After 11 years, Journey overstays its welcome on ‘Freedom’

Journey, Journey Freedom, Neal Schon, Jonathan Cain, Arnel Pineda, Randy Jackson

Journey, “Freedom.”

New Journey music will always be worth a listen while Neal Schon is manning guitar. At least until you get to his solo.

Freedom
Journey
BMG, July 8
5/10

After that, you’re on your own in 2022. Buyer beware.

Schon will always be the master of an underrated and important musical craft: pop guitar solos. He comes up with standalone lead melodies worth their own writing credits. Very few guitarists alternate what could be memorable, standalone melodies with absolute shedding as well as Schon. His leads are often songs within songs.

That said, Journey is about to release Freedom, its first record of new music in 11 years. Apparently, they’re trying to make up for lost time, as there’s 15 songs which, in this case, has more filler than a giant, overstuffed exploding Twinkie.



Everyone of a certain age growing up in the Bay Area, grew up with Journey. Love them or hate them, Journey was a permanent, important part of the local musical landscape. Many of us – me included – saw Journey at their first big concert and remembers their prime with great fondness.

But there’s no reason why anyone – even diehards – need 15 new subpar Journey songs. All it does is muddy the water and let a lot of time-killing get in the way of a few highlights. Unfortunately, there’s not many.

The downside with being super successful during a band’s first decade – which puts you in maybe the top 1 percent of serious bands – is that you will always be compared to your salad days. Journey is teetering on its 50th anniversary, which, even as Schon as the lone original member, is rarified air. I give credit to legacy bands who still try to make new music, despite everyone (but perhaps the band) knowing their best days are decades past.

But if I went to a Journey show in 2022, and they were actually trying to tour on Freedom by playing more than one or two songs, I would feel ripped off. Even nine or 10 new songs on an album from this version of Journey would be too many.



The record launches well, with three keepers out of the first four songs. “Together We Run” is classic Journey drama-pop. Jonathan Cain still understands a keyboard hook and this is modern Journey trying to be Journey. Arnel Pinedo is a great singer. He’s not that other guy, but no one is and we’re all over it by now (it’s been 15 years, believe it or not).

Second song “Don’t Give Up on Us” has a bit of “Separate Ways” in it, but not nearly as good. Like a lot of songs on Freedom, they band fails to finish the song after starting with a promising idea. Many end up with one or two decent parts, instead of three or four (not counting the guitar solos, which we’ve covered). They just don’t close the deal anymore.

Discounting the playing, which is always session-musician quality (former “American Idol” judge Randy Jackson returns to the bad after more than 30 years), “Still Believe in Love,” is the first throwaway. Journey quickly makes up for it with single “You Got the Best of Me,” one of the few songs up to Journey standards. You’ve probably heard it before, but it sticks.

“Live To Love Again” sounds like Survivor, a band that thrived for a few years by sounding like watered-down Journey. This would be watered-down Survivor. “The Way We Used to Be” just isn’t good despite Pineda’s best efforts and “Come Away With Me” shows a little backbone, but just kills more time.



Drummer Deen Castronovo, still part of the band despite Narada Michael Walden playing on most of the record, takes vocals on “After Glow,” and does a decent job. But the song tries to be emotionally moving without much of a hook, which just doesn’t work.

“Let It Rain” is a rocker and a keeper, with a big riff and grittier vocals from Pineda. But like much of Freedom, it stomps down a good premise, though maybe that’s OK, as Schon’s shredding is just unleashed. The same could be said of “Holdin On,” though it’s another song that feels stunted, as does “All Day and All Night.”

“Don’t Go” makes absolutely no case not to. It’s the filler of filler that sounds like it was written in less than 10 minutes. “United We Stand” is wince-inducing, like watching an aging All-Star try to make a comeback after too many years away from the game.

“Life Rolls on” is OK and “Beautiful As You Are,” is nice in a “Mother, Father” kind of way, without the sneaky hook, and it unnecessarily drenches great vocals in a wash of lightweight keyboards. Even with some first rate drumming broken out near the end, sometimes, less is better, fellas.

Follow music critic Tony Hicks at Twitter.com/TonyBaloney1967.

(11) Comments

  1. Rich Hale

    The biggest problem is the muddy production, especially the bass and drums which kills the life of the performance. Makes it really hard to hear the potential of the songs.

  2. Ross Muir

    Pretty much agree across the board, Tony, other than a song or two here and there (but then favourite songs is subjective at the end of the musical day). Something else very amiss for me on Freedom is the sub-par production and a cluttered mix with pretty much zero high-end, as I made mention of in my own review. http://www.fabricationshq.com/2022-reviews.html

  3. Trent

    I can hear some production errors, especially on Beautiful as you are when volume decreases 3/4 way through song but, music is great. If I produced it I might go back and fix these errors for the second printing. I'd probably start now while the first printing is still going. But, what do I know I'm just a listener and I can overlook the errors.

  4. FNP

    Contemporary Journey band has been overly critiqued by purists for years, but the sold out concert tickets proved them wrong. In fact, they have expanded their fan base which now includes younger generations. Their success expanded further during their global tour to untapped countries, particularly in Asia. In the same manner, the final arbiters of the Freedom Album are the buyers. Most of the songs were recorded remotely due to the pandemic, from Manila, FL, CA. So, it's amazing how they pulled this off. The songs can be categorized into 3 groups, Classic Rock, Arena Rock & Ballads. You get 4-6 songs per type, what a treat! Instead, they criticized the number of random songs included. The way they look at Journey is like a half empty glass and use a magnifying glass to look for flaws, thinking that simple folks will take their word, hook, line and sinker. We may not have the snobbery of the purist mind, but let this sink into you heads. Their songs resonate to all who went through horrendous 3 years of health issues, death, and livelihood challenges. So, please spare us with your misplaced pontifications. More often than not, beauty is not seen in perfection, but to create and triumph against all odds.

  5. FNP

    Contemporary Journey band has been overly critiqued by purists for years, but the sold out concert tickets proved them wrong. In fact, they have expanded their fan base which now includes younger generations. Their success expanded further during their global tour to untapped countries, particularly in Asia. In the same manner, the final arbiters of the Freedom Album are the buyers. Most of the songs were recorded remotely due to the pandemic, from Manila, FL, CA. So, it's amazing how they pulled this off. The songs can be categorized into 3 groups, Classic Rock, Arena Rock & Ballads. You get 4-6 songs per type, what a treat! Instead, they criticize the number of random songs included. They look at Journey like a half empty glass and use a magnifying glass to look for flaws, thinking that simple folks will take their word, hook, line and sinker. We may not have the snobbery of a purist mind, but let this sink into you heads. Their songs resonate to all who went through horrendous 3 years of health issues, death, and livelihood challenges. So, please spare us your misplaced pontifications. More often than not, beauty is not seen in perfection, but to create and triumph against all odds.

  6. BigheadRick

    I LOVE the album. I can't find a bad track on it. This album has more hooks than my grandfather's tackle box. Eclipse was a showcase for Schon and he deserved that. This is a band album. Everyone is allowed to shine and nobody shines more than Arnel. He has assumed the role and this is his band now. He is no longer Steve Perry's replacement. I was tremendously impressed by his growth from Revelation and Eclipse. I don't care about a few production issues, but that's me. Any classic band is lucky to break even on albums these days. In my opinion, musically, this is the best album Journey has released since Raised On Radio.

  7. Steve shapiro

    It amazes me how critics like you that write a review, look to surgically dissect each song and performance as if it is a poorly written essay by some inept college student needing endless grammatical corrections. HOW MANY TIMES HAVE YOU ACTUALLY LISTENED TO IT?? The album is a miraculous masterpiece!!!! Considering how it was recorded and also the fact that it is actually a musical product of the pandemic, it is quite an accomplishment. Journey cant win. If they record 3 minute ballads, they are accused of being " commercial " and repetitious. If they stretch out and take some chances, like they did with FREEDOM, they are accused of not staying true to form and trying to not sound like themselves. Yes there are some mixing and production issues but they have been greatly exaggerated. Listening to the CD on a $2000 component system is an absolute pleasure. The songwriting is in some cases, breathtaking. Arnel Pineda finally comes into his own with an originally developed style that does just fine, Neal Schon fires out some of his best work yet on this one and the effect Of Narada Michael Walden on drums is truly a step in the right direction. Its not easy for a band that has recorded 14 albums to record a 15th and have it NOT sound like anything that they have ever done or that anyone else hasn't done. I mean come on, everything that an artist records sounds like something that has been recorded before by either themselves or someone else. Nobodys perfect, not even Journey, but they sure come close. I give Freedom an A-

  8. TMich

    Well saw them live tonight Covid aside now they were playing out of their shoes and having fun, fun, fun so so was us the audience. Not much on Judging since I just haven’t done what this band has done. The new songs reminded me of their late 60’s stuff with more a hard rock edge which at the concert tonight - who showed up to drive a Journey song to a new level - Kirk Hammett from Metallica and Journey really flew showing what talented band mates Journey are. Stand out time.

  9. Lizi

    Hát, én egyszerűen imádom, nem tudok betelni vele. Nem érdekel az összehasonlítás, boncolgatás, ugy tetszik ahogy van.🙂 Translation: Well, I just love it, I can't get enough of it. I'm not interested in comparison, dissection, I like it the way it is.🙂

  10. Cheryl J Adkins

    Opinions are like... Well, you know. I think the album is great. Sorry, you don't. Maybe you spent too much time dissecting it instead of listening.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *