ALBUM REVIEW: Yes returns to its golden era on ‘Mirror to the Sky’

YES Mirror to the Sky, Alan White, Billy Sherwood, Geoff Downes, Jon Davison, Steve Howe, Yes, YES band

YES, “Mirror to the Sky.”

It can be really sad when bands change with the times. Remember the feeling of hearing the cheesy synths of Jefferson Starship and not the gritty psychedelia of Jefferson Airplane? Well, Yes is back with a new album that sounds more like the band’s 1971 classic, Fragile, than its 1985 MTV hit, “Owner of a Lonely Heart.”

Mirror to the Sky
Yes

InsideOutMusic, May 23
8/10
Get the album on Amazon Music.

Guitarist Steve Howe and company have created a remarkable piece of nostalgia that revisits the English band’s signature prog-rock sound but manages to sound fresh and vibrant, rather than like a tired retreading of older material. From the science fictional imagery and classic logo of the cover art to the throbbing and complicated bass lines on songs like “Cut From the Stars,” Mirror to the Sky, feels like an amazing find in a thrift store record bin rather than a new offering from the band.

The album’s got it all. Nine-minute jam “Luminosity” gets theatrical with noodly synthesizers, ponderous guitar melodies and Jon Davison’s powerful vocals sung in duet with a woman. The pair delivers some pretty epic lyrics, including, “Dream the night came calling from forest mist/ The light in man leaves none to resist/ Voiced the thunder to hearts of brotherhood/ Perceive the arc man’s rising.”



There are four songs on the album that clock in at over nine minutes in length, but rather than extended jazz odysseys where the band simply vamps endlessly over a simple chord progression, the songs are carefully constructed and elaborate tapestries of sound that assemble musical elements like Legos into complicated sonic cathedrals.

The new album is very much a continuation of sonic trajectory staked out on the band’s 2021 release, The Quest. A key ingredient in the band’s new old sound is that guitarist extraordinaire Steve Howe has taken the helm as producer.

The album’s 13-and-half-minute title track builds from delicate guitar and gauzy keys to a musical duel in which strident guitars square off with thunderous bass lines in an elaborate call and response. Davison’s eventual falsetto vocals lay on a bed of acoustic guitar and lush string orchestrations as he sings, “What the shadow minds behind the third eye spies in vain define/ The essence they fail to posses and so resist all they cannot control/ Their forces then despise the very Soul and/ Its inseparable ties to the limitless sacred skies.” Put that in your pipe and smoke it.



“Circles of Time” is a gentle acoustic ballad that’s on the lesser end of five minutes, which makes sense, since the song seems to be about seizing the day.

“That clock on the wall/ Like the shadow of a noose/ Is a ticking time bomb/ Orchestrating and dictating our every move,” Davison sings.

It seems as if Yes has circled back to its golden age. Despite the deaths and lineup changes over the years, with Steve Howe in the producer’s chair, we may have more new gems that feel like old ones.

An earlier version of this story incorrectly listed when Steve Howe joined Yes. We regret the error.

Follow writer David Gill at Twitter.com/saxum_paternus.

(22) Comments

  1. Rich

    I am a loyal fan and have seen every lineup of yes .BUT listening to them live in concert is like listening to a cover band. Sometimes you just need to know when to pack it in.

  2. Mike Young

    Yeah you're gonna catch some heat for calling Howe a founding member. Love his stuff and he's integral to their sound but he came in on their third album. Thanks for the review! Looking forward to checking this one out

  3. Olias

    It's all just a parody of many many years hard work and some of the world's great musicians Howe is a great guitarist but cannot revisit the collaborations of Wakeman Anderson and Squire and still call himself and his "mates" the eponymous Yes

  4. Anthony

    No one can successfully imitate the voice, the songwriting, the arranging, the lyrics of Jon Anderson. Call this band anything but Yes and they might be great but they have more thsn proven themselves a mere shadow of Jon Anderson and Chris Squires's Yes. Imitation never rings true.

  5. S D

    Not Jon Anderson, nothing compares. It is like listening to a cover band, bring back as many of the early line up. Pre fragile

  6. Massimiliano

    mediocre music without creativity, there are no real Yes melodies. the singer fails to give the right pathos so his voice remains static. I loved Yes up to Magnification and I followed them up to the tour they did with Wakeman, then selfishness took some of them by the throat. Now Howe is left who would do better to close everything. History was written and not only by him. mediocre music without creativity, there are no real Yes melodies. the singer fails to give the right pathos so his voice remains static. I loved Yes up to Magnification and I followed them up to the tour they did with Wakeman, then selfishness took some of them by the throat. Now Howe is left who would do better to close everything. History was written and not only by him.

  7. Todd

    You know, I'd rather the Fragile lineup of Yes had stayed together, but they didn't. I enjoy just about every incarnation of Yes, except the last one. It's not like Yes with Jon Anderson didn't make their share of dreck. But I'll give the new material a shot, just like I've done with every new Yes release. Not like it's a major investment of time or money. I'll either like it or not. Doesn't affect me one way or another.

  8. Eric

    There have been so many different versions of Yes that it's not really possible to make an objective analysis. I know I will flamed to a crispy crunch for saying this, but the album that critics hail as quintessential Yes (Close to the Edge) is MY least favorite, and who can forget the train wreck of Drama. There are also other Yes albums featuring original members that fall short of what these guys are capable of. I'm not trying to sugarcoat this latest effort but I really respect the talent of Steve Howe and will at least give this new one a listen before condemning into the substantial heap of other sub-par Yes records.

  9. John grant

    Absolute crap, and just marginally better than the last effort. It pains me to hear Davisons pathetic wishy washy vocals along with his lyrics. According to Howe this is 'a Yes that works'. This isn't because they're better than before, rather because he's in charge along with his fellow cronies. In addition he managed to squeeze Anderson out due to his obvious hostility to him This isn't Yes, it's a farce and Howe is behind it all. He'll be the next to go and hopefully that will be the end of it.

  10. Eurico

    This is an effort to be sounds like Yes, but isn’t Yes. without Chris Squire and Jon Anderson no Yes. It’s a body without soul. Please, Steve Howe stop using the name Yes. You are a good musician, incredible guitar player you should create a band with other name. Sorry.

    1. Ben

      YES is bigger than whatever lineup you enjoyed. It's an institution that will outlast us all. Also, come on dude ... Howe is killing it for his age. We are lucky to get this output from him!! To see him on stage playing all these songs with a solid band is fantastic. Chris and Alan wanted it this way so, and I'm here for it.

  11. Ben

    Been a fan since I was 3 years old, Great up on YES vinyl. This is their best record in 20 years, I LOVE IT!!!

  12. MJ Hoffman

    Nothing beats the OG lineup - (or LINEUPS!) but I don't care. This newest release had me hooked with the first track - far better than The Quest in my opinion. CTTE and Fragile was a long time ago, friends. I'm grateful for whatever new music Howe, Peter Gabriel, Ian Anderson, or any of my fav continue to delight us with. This is a really good Yes album - and I get to spin it w my 21 yo son. It doesn't have to be Relayer for me to like it. -A Progger from Boston

  13. VG

    Gotta say that this incarnation is getting their sea legs and delivering very good new fresh music. It Is Yes Music. This album is easily as good as the excellent Fly from Here and the FFH Return Trip (somewhat improved). It at least as good as all the albums back to and including Open Your Eyes. I actually like Talk, and Union, Drama and ABWH. Jon's been putting out nothing, Rick is putting retread music, and the ARW version of version didn't do anything but add extra noodling to the existing great songs. So Howe's assessment of "this is a Yes that works", is very accurate and fair. So, YES,keep adding to the Yes canon, the not yes w/o Anderson or Wakeman only crowd will just have to play those crappy solo albums to stay happy, or they can back to the Ladder or Keys for some 30ish year old fresh stuff. Or you could open your mind and listen to all the Yes Music... it's all pretty good, and today it's getting better as it goes on.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *